ReachRxResearch
Home
Research
Sign Up
Paper Mills in Dermatology: A Cross-Sectional Study of Retracted Publications
Back to Research Hub
  1. Home
  2. Research Hub
  3. Paper Mills in Dermatology: A Cross-Sect…

Paper Mills in Dermatology: A Cross-Sectional Study of Retracted Publications

British Journal of Dermatology·September 5Open Access
DermatologySafety signalCutaneous OncologyDermatologyCross-Sectional StudyMixed

Summary

View source

What was studied

Cross-sectional analysis of paper mill-associated retractions in dermatology using the Retraction Watch Database, identifying 118 paper mill articles among 1,209 dermatology retractions, with data extracted on study design, topic, research integrity markers, country of origin, journal metrics, and time to retraction.

Key findings

Paper mill articles represented 9.8% (118/1,209) of dermatology retractions; none appeared before 2018, with a peak of >50 in 2023. China accounted for 86% of cases, 47% focused on cutaneous oncology, 79% lacked ethics approval, none reported data availability or pre-registration, and mean time to retraction was 957 days — not significantly different from non-paper mill retractions (P = 0.53).

Study limitations

- Study is limited to articles explicitly labelled 'paper mill' in the Retraction Watch Database, likely underestimating true prevalence. - Cross-sectional design captures a snapshot and cannot assess causality or future trends. - Reliance on a single database may miss retractions not yet catalogued.

Clinical implications

Clinicians and journal editors should treat missing data availability statements, absent ethics approval, and experimental designs focused on cutaneous oncology as red flags for paper mill activity. Mandating data availability statements and strengthening pre-publication screening are key steps to protect the dermatology evidence base.

Caveats

  • Level of evidence assigned as 4 (cross-sectional/descriptive); this study does not evaluate a clinical intervention, so evidence hierarchy application is approximate.
  • Sex of study populations was not reported in the abstract or results and could not be tagged.
  • The sample size of 118 reflects only explicitly labelled paper mill retractions; actual paper mill infiltration in dermatology is likely higher and may not be fully captured.

Related Questions

Explore related topics

How can journal editors detect paper mill submissions before publication in dermatology?What are the research integrity red flags most associated with fabricated or paper mill studies?How does paper mill retraction prevalence in dermatology compare to other medical specialties?

Publication Details

Year
2026
Journal
British Journal of Dermatology
Sample Size
n=118
Source
View article
Keep scrolling
More content below.
Up Next