A randomized between-subjects experiment (N=266 U.S. college students, 2025) tested whether identical ChatGPT-generated sexual health passages on three topics (sexual communication, body image, sexual pleasure/safety) were evaluated differently when attributed to genAI, an academic expert, a community health professional, or a peer/social media influencer.
GenAI-attributed content was rated significantly lower than human-attributed content on all five outcomes (perceived accuracy/clarity, warmth/helpfulness, trustworthiness, self-efficacy, and willingness to act); academic expert attribution scored highest across the board, and effects persisted after controlling for genAI familiarity and attitudes. Source effects on willingness to act were strongest for sexual pleasure/safety (all three sources differed significantly) and absent for sexual communication.
Single southeastern U.S. university limits generalizability; sample was 63% women; community health professional and peer/influencer conditions had to be collapsed due to high attribution confusion (26.6%); outcome measures were study-specific and not psychometrically validated; content was produced with an older model (ChatGPT v3.5); intentions were measured rather than actual behavior.
When using genAI tools in sexual health education, pairing AI-generated content with visible human endorsement or facilitation — especially for sensitive topics like sexual pleasure and body image — is likely to improve student trust and willingness to act on the information.
Explore related topics