ReachRxResearch
Home
Research
Sign Up
The 50 most-cited primary studies in penile prosthesis surgery: An all-time bibliometric analysis
Back to Research Hub
  1. Home
  2. Research Hub
  3. The 50 most-cited primary studies in pen…

The 50 most-cited primary studies in penile prosthesis surgery: An all-time bibliometric analysis

International Journal of Impotence Research·August 31Open Access
Urology & NephrologyLimited evidenceErectile DysfunctionPeyronie'S DiseaseBibliometric AnalysisPenile Prosthesis ImplantationAdultAmbicorAMS 700CXColoplast TitanMentor Alpha-1

Summary

View source

What was studied

Bibliometric analysis of the 50 most-cited primary studies in penile prosthesis (PP) surgery, searched from Web of Science Core Collection inception through April 21, 2025, to characterize citation trends, research themes, study designs, evidence levels, and academic contributions across the field's history.

Key findings

The 50 studies (published 1977–2017) accumulated 5,652 total citations (median 105; range 75–215). Most were retrospective observational studies (82%) rated Level 4 evidence (56%). The top-cited article was Carson et al. (2000) on AMS 700CX outcomes (215 citations). The Journal of Urology published 56% of included studies. US institutions produced 76% of the corpus; Steven K. Wilson authored or co-authored 10 of 50 studies.

Study limitations

- Citation count favors older studies with more time to accrue; 'obliteration by incorporation' may obscure seminal contributions. - Restricted to Web of Science Core Collection, potentially missing non-indexed or non-English literature. - No kappa statistic reported for inter-rater agreement on OCEBM level assignment.

Clinical implications

The foundational PP literature is dominated by retrospective, low-evidence-level studies from a small group of US authors and institutions — clinicians should interpret historical benchmarks (infection rates, satisfaction data) with awareness of this evidence gap. Prospective, multicenter, and geographically diverse studies are still needed to guide modern practice.

Caveats

  • Sample size of n=50 refers to the number of included publications, not patients — no aggregate patient-level N is reported.
  • Several authors declared consulting relationships with device manufacturers (Coloplast, Boston Scientific), which may influence thematic framing of the discussion.
  • The study includes a transgender patient subgroup (female-to-male) within 'special populations,' so the male-only sex tag is an approximation of the primary population.
Show all 4
  • This is a bibliometric study of other studies — the Level 4 evidence tag reflects the predominant level of the analyzed literature, not this analysis itself, which has no standard LOE designation.

Related Questions

Explore related topics

What are the current infection rates and prevention strategies for inflatable penile prosthesis implantation?How does penile prosthesis surgery compare to other ED treatments in patient satisfaction outcomes?What is the evidence for penile prosthesis implantation in men with Peyronie's disease and erectile dysfunction?

Publication Details

Year
2026
Journal
International Journal of Impotence Research
Sample Size
n=50
Source
View article
Keep scrolling
More content below.
Up Next